E21 Lecture #15

Intellectual Property: Laws and Issues

What is it?

Why do we have intellectual property laws?

In order to promote art and science.

Trade Secret

Trade secret laws allow companies to keep secrets.

A trade secret must:

  1. have novelty
  2. represent an economic investment to the claimant,
  3. have involved some effort in development, and
  4. the company must show that it made some effort to keep the information a secret.

Most well-known example: Coca-Cola

In the technical world: Industrial Light & Magic

Problems:

Copyright

Patent

A patent is the strongest form of protection for intellectual property because it gives the developer a monopoly over the use of that idea for a period of 17 years.

Ideas, mathematical algorithms, scientific principles, laws of nature, and mental processes can not be patented.

To give someone the right to these things would inhibit scientific thought and advancement.

A patent claim must:

  1. fall within the category of permissible subject matter
  2. have utility
  3. have novelty
  4. must be nonobvious

Software Patents

Computer software faces its greatest challenge with number 1.

For the purpose of a patent, software is generally considered a process.

70s and 80s, the argument was the software could be duplicated by a mental process, which is inappropriate subject matter.

90s, attention focuses on how computer algorithms are different from mathematical algorithms (if at all)

  • Freeman-Walter-Abele test: mathematical algorithms are abstract ideas and unpatentable unless there is a practical application of the algorithm. In previous cases a practical application of an algorithm consisted of data being transformed through mathematical calculations to produce a smooth waveform display on a mointor. A practical application required physical elements or steps.
  • In State Street Bank & Trust Col v. Signature Financial Group (1998), Inc., the Court of Customs and Patent Appeals held that "the transformation of data, representing discrete dollar amounts, by a machine trough a series of mathematical calculations into a final share price, constitutes ap ractical application of a mathematical agorithm, formula, or calculation, because it produces a useful, concrete and tangible result - a final share price".
  • This removes the "physical element" aspect of patentable software
  • This requirement now becomes that a computer program, method, or process must produce a useful, concrete, and tangible result.

The concern now is that there are too many software patents

  • Before you sell a piece of software you have to do a patent search
  • The organization of software by the patent office is poor at best, and is continuously being reorganized by the USPTO
  • This makes software development a risky business, and creates barriers to entry

Digital System Patents

You no longer have to provide source code something like a robot controller that relies on software to run (you used to).

You do have to say that it relies on software and give an explanation of the function of that software. There has to be sufficient explanation that a person "conversant in the field" could recreate it. (Robotic Vision Systems, Inc. v. View Engineering, Inc., 1997).

This also shows that you must describe the "best mode" for controlling a device in your patent. If the best mode is software, you must disclose the function of the software.

You might want to provide the source code to the patent office to help keep future patent seekers from infringing on your patent or from trying to patent something you already created (Translogic Corporation v. Tele Engineering, Inc, 1997). This works in two ways

  • It will make it easier for a patent seeker to do a patent search.
  • It will keep others from trying to patent a piece of software that you have already created.